Environment Secretary Dame Angela Eagle has cautioned against the use of loopholes that undermine the spirit of the government's ban on executive bonuses in the water sector. The warning comes as a review of the bonus ban rule commences today, with Dame Angela requesting it be wide-ranging to close avenues that reward failure.
Since its introduction, the government's ban has already prevented over £10 million from reaching water bosses. In the last financial year alone, nine water companies triggered the ban, resulting in more than £6.5 million in potential bonuses being blocked. Despite this, some executives saw their total pay increase during 2025-26, even with continued poor performance.
Ofwat has expressed concerns that retention payments and significant, unexplained increases in base pay risk eroding public trust and undermining the intention of the bonus ban. The public is invited to contribute to Ofwat’s four-week call for evidence, which closes on 10 December. The findings will shape the government's efforts to enhance accountability within the water sector, including through a strengthened Water Bill.
Dame Angela Eagle stated, "People are sick of seeing water bosses profit while rivers are polluted and customers are repeatedly let down. A wide-ranging review launching today will ensure that failure doesn’t pay, whatever name the payment goes by. The bonus ban was the first step. Where there are loopholes, I want them closed."
This action follows the first joint report from regulators, designed to prevent underperforming companies from hiding behind disparate assessments. By consolidating their data, regulators are closing gaps that previously allowed failing firms to receive positive ratings from one body while falling short with another. The report is published alongside the Environment Agency’s Environmental Performance Assessment Report, which highlights that pollution incidents remain excessively high, with only one company achieving the top four-star rating.
Companies receiving a one-star rating, including Southern Water, Thames Water, South West Water, and Yorkshire Water, will automatically have bonuses blocked for their executives. This also applies to any company responsible for a Category 1 pollution incident, defined as having a major, serious, persistent, or extensive impact on the environment, people, or property.
The Environment Secretary will also outline specific improvement actions for each water company, focusing on reducing leakage, achieving sustained decreases in pollution incidents, and enhancing customer satisfaction. This initiative is part of the government's broader strategy to empower the public regarding water management. The Environment Secretary has previously set clear expectations for the upcoming Price Review, urging companies to deliver better value for households facing financial pressures. Eight new regional water councils are being established to provide local input, and a strengthened Water Bill aims to grant the public greater control and accountability.




